Comedy (OVA) Reviews
Comedy
1242
Title(s): Comedy
Kigeki (Japanese)
Комедия (Russian)
喜劇 (Japanese)
Creator: Kazuto Nakazawa, Rika Hataketa
Genres: Drama, Fantasy, Supernatural
Age Group: Teenagers (May contain bloody violence, bad language, nudity)
Vintage: April 6, 1999
Status: Completed
Summary: During Ireland's War of Independence, a five year old girl set out to save her village from the English army, by trying to find the rumored skilled swordsman living in a nearby castle, who only takes books of a certain genre as payment, only known as the Black Swordsman.
Reviews
Summary: (6 reviews) Write A Review
Excellent 4 reviews
67%
67%
Good 2 reviews
33%
33%
Average 0 reviews
0%
0%
Poor 0 reviews
0%
0%
Very Poor 0 reviews
0%
0%
Nice short story anime, but where is the Irish feel?
Written by kim333 on September 17, 2015 at 12:43 AM
Overall Rating
Good
Story: 4
Dialogue: 4
Animation: 4
Entertainment: 4
I enjoyed this anime, but to me, it makes more sense to place it in what is today Germany. The "Black Forest" exists today, and it refers to a wooded and mountainous area that sits on the border between France and Germany. The trees are evergreens, hence the name (dark and thick foliage year round).

The songs in the anime are beautiful classics by Schubert. By the way, if there were a rating for soundtrack, that would get a 5 star. Songs featured include the famous "Ave Maria" and a poem by Goethe set to music by Schubert, "Der Erlkoenig". They are in German.

The castle of the black knight could come from many European folkstales, including German tales. The Bavarian Castle of Neuschwanstein was built more recently, but that's the style. So when would the English have attacked a village in Germany? The Hundred Years War (1337-1453) seems to be a candidate.

I don't know if Germany is the right place for the story, but that's how I watched it. It made more sense to me that way and I was able to better immerse myself in the story.
0 out of 0 people found this review helpful.
Popular Anime
Top Contributors
Top Contributors
satoshiandkinki 70,112 files
Nanilist 56,826 files
smf 26,294 files
rension23 15,514 files
10,792 files
Little_Wolf-18 9,112 files
Numisma 4,054 files
Zenixus 4,028 files
manalosana21 3,740 files
lanaiblur 2,792 files
Recent Reviews
Tensei shitara Dainana Ouji Datta node, Kimama ni Majutsu wo Kiwamemasu
Good
Natsume Yuujinchou Shichi
must watch anime if you like peaceful environment and a funny cat
One Piece
I tried to watch but the storyline is so basic that its pretty much set for preteens its a cartoon labelled anime but if...
Yu Yu Hakusho: Ghost Files
Excellent
Usagi Drop
Excellent
Fate/stay night
I LOVE IT
The Twelve Kingdoms
Excellent
Dead Dead Demons Dededede Destruction
Please and thanks
Genshiken Nidaime (TV 2013)
if you like Genshiken
High School DxD BorN
Excellent